Your 401(k) is yours — it doesn’t disappear when you quit. But what you do with it matters enormously. The best move for most people: roll it to an IRA for lower fees and more investment options.

Your Four Options

Option Taxes Penalty Fees Best For
Roll to an IRA $0 $0 Typically lowest Most people
Roll to new employer’s 401(k) $0 $0 Varies One-account simplicity
Leave in old plan $0 $0 Old plan fees Good plan with low fees
Cash out Full income tax 10% if under 59½ N/A Almost never recommended

The Cost of Cashing Out

$50,000 cashed out at age 35, 22% bracket:

Item Amount
401(k) balance $50,000
Federal tax (22%) -$11,000
10% early withdrawal penalty -$5,000
State tax (~5%) -$2,500
You receive $31,500
Lost growth over 25 years (8%) $342,400
True cost $360,900

Cashing out a $50,000 401(k) at 35 costs you over $360,000 by retirement.

Vesting: What You Actually Own

Years of Service Cliff Vesting Graded Vesting
Less than 1 year 0% of match 0% of match
1 year 0% 0%
2 years 0% 20%
3 years 100% 40%
4 years 100% 60%
5 years 100% 80%
6 years 100% 100%

Your own contributions are always 100% vested. Only the employer match has a vesting schedule.

What Happens by Balance Size

Balance What Happens If You Do Nothing
Under $1,000 Employer may cash you out (check mailed, taxes withheld)
$1,000-$5,000 Employer may roll into an IRA for you automatically
$5,000-$7,000 Employer may force distribution or auto-rollover
Over $7,000 You can leave it in the plan indefinitely

IRA Rollover: Step by Step

Step Action Key Detail
1 Open an IRA (if you don’t have one) Fidelity, Vanguard, Schwab are popular choices
2 Contact your old 401(k) plan administrator Request a direct rollover (trustee-to-trustee)
3 Provide your new IRA account information Custodian name, account number, address
4 Plan sends funds directly to the IRA Takes 1-3 weeks
5 Invest the funds in your IRA Don’t leave it in cash/money market

Important: Always choose a direct rollover (check made payable to new custodian). If the check is made payable to you, the old plan withholds 20% for taxes, and you have 60 days to deposit the full amount (including the withheld 20% from your own funds) to avoid penalties.

IRA vs. 401(k) Comparison

Feature IRA 401(k)
Investment options Virtually unlimited Limited to plan menu
Average fees 0.03-0.20% (index funds) 0.50-1.50% (plan average)
Loan option No Yes (if plan allows)
Creditor protection Varies by state Federal protection (ERISA)
Rule of 55 No Yes (penalty-free at 55 if separated)
Required minimum distributions Age 73 Age 73 (or retirement if later, for current employer)

The Bottom Line

For most people, rolling to an IRA is the best option — lower fees, more investment choices, and full control. Leave it in the old plan only if the plan has excellent low-cost funds. Never cash out unless it’s a true financial emergency and you’ve exhausted every other option.

Related: What Happens If You Withdraw 401(k) Early? | What Happens to Your 401(k) If Your Company Goes Bankrupt?