Best Gas Cards — Quick Comparison
| Card | Annual Fee | Gas Reward Rate | Cap | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PenFed Platinum Rewards Visa | $0 | 5x points (~5% back) | None | Best overall gas rate |
| Costco Anywhere Visa by Citi | $0 ($65 Costco req.) | 4% on gas | $7,000/yr | Costco members |
| Citi Custom Cash | $0 | 5% if gas is top category | $500/month | Flexible single category |
| Amex Blue Cash Preferred | $95 | 3% US gas stations | None | Multi-category earner |
| Amex Blue Cash Everyday | $0 | 3% US gas stations | None | Free grocery + gas card |
| Chase Freedom Flex (rotating) | $0 | 5% when gas is a category (Q3 historically) | $1,500/quarter | Seasonal-use rotation |
| Bank of America Customized Cash | $0 | 3% on selected category (inc. gas) | $2,500/quarter | Customizable |
Best for Highest Consistent Gas Rate: PenFed Platinum Rewards Visa Signature
Annual fee: $0 | Gas rate: 5x points at gas stations ($1 = 5 PenFed points) | Points value: ~1 cent each = ~5% back | Membership: PenFed Credit Union (open to anyone)
The PenFed Platinum Rewards earns 5 points per dollar at gas stations with no cap — the highest consistent gas rate on a no-fee card. Points redeem for statement credits, travel, and merchandise at approximately 1 cent each.
Annual savings at various spending levels:
| Monthly Gas Spend | Annual at 5% (PenFed) | Annual at 3% (BCP) | Annual at 1.5% (baseline) |
|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | $60 | $36 | $18 |
| $200 | $120 | $72 | $36 |
| $300 | $180 | $108 | $54 |
PenFed membership: Open to everyone. Apply online, then apply for the card.
Other PenFed rates: 3x at supermarkets, 2x at restaurants, 1x everywhere else.
Best for Costco Shoppers: Costco Anywhere Visa by Citi
Annual fee: $0 (requires Costco membership, $65+/year) | Gas rate: 4% on gas worldwide (up to $7,000/year, then 1%) | Other rates: 3% restaurants/travel, 2% Costco, 1% everywhere
The Costco Anywhere Visa earns 4% on all gas purchases everywhere — including Costco’s own fuel stations (which already have some of the lowest prices in most markets). Combining low Costco gas prices with 4% back yields the highest raw savings per gallon.
Limitation: Reward comes as an annual certificate redeemable at Costco (February statement). Cash value only available in-store.
Best for: Regular Costco shoppers who fill up at Costco gas stations.
Best for Flexible Category: Citi Custom Cash
Annual fee: $0 | Gas rate: 5% if gas is your top monthly spending category (up to $500/month)
If gas is consistently your largest monthly purchase, the Citi Custom Cash automatically applies 5% to it. At $400/month, you earn $20/month = $240/year with no cap management needed (below $500/month).
Limitation: Rate drops to 1% above $500/month in gas. Heavy commuters may exceed this in winter months.
Pairing: Combine with a 2% flat card (Citi Double Cash) — 5% on gas + 2% on everything else = optimal no-fee combination.
Best Multi-Category Gas Card: Amex Blue Cash Preferred
Annual fee: $95 | Gas rate: 3% at US gas stations with no cap
The Blue Cash Preferred isn’t the highest gas rate, but it’s part of a broader earning structure: 6% groceries + 6% streaming + 3% gas + 3% transit. For most households, the combined category value substantially exceeds the annual fee.
Gas-only break-even vs. no-fee cards: If you hold the Blue Cash Everyday ($0 fee, 3% gas) vs. Preferred ($95 fee, 3% gas), the gas earning is identical. The $95 fee is justified by 6% groceries, not the gas category.
Best No-Fee Alternative: Amex Blue Cash Everyday
Annual fee: $0 | Gas rate: 3% at US gas stations (up to $6,000/year) | Also: 3% US supermarkets, 3% US online retail
The free version of the Blue Cash earns the same 3% on gas without the annual fee. If groceries and streaming aren’t significant spend categories for you, the Everyday is the better choice.
Seasonal Option: Chase Freedom Flex (Q3 Gas)
The Freedom Flex historically activates gas stations as a 5% category in Q3 (July-September). Up to $1,500/quarter at 5% = $75 back in that quarter alone. If you drive more in summer (road trips, commuting), the Flex can be a great supplemental card for gas in those months.
Strategy: Use the Freedom Flex for 5% when gas is active (Q3). Use PenFed or Citi Custom Cash the rest of the year.
Gas Rewards by Monthly Spending
| Monthly Gas Spend | PenFed 5% | Costco Citi 4% | Custom Cash 5% | BCP 3% | BCA 3% (no fee) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $75 | $45/yr | $36/yr | $45/yr | $27/yr | $27/yr |
| $150 | $90/yr | $72/yr | $90/yr | $54/yr | $54/yr |
| $250 | $150/yr | $120/yr | $150/yr | $90/yr | $90/yr |
| $500/mo cap | $300/yr | $240/yr | $300/yr (cap) | $180/yr | $180/yr |
Gas Station vs. Wholesale Club Rewards
Not all “gas” earns the same. Know where your card applies:
| Location | PenFed 5x | Costco Citi 4% | BCP 3% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Branded station (Shell, BP, Chevron) | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
| Costco Gas | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ (warehouse, not gas station MCC) |
| Sam’s Club Gas | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ |
| Grocery store gas (Kroger, Safeway) | ❌ (coded grocery) | ❌ | ❌ |
| Superstore gas (Walmart) | ❌ (coded superstore) | ❌ | ❌ |
Important: Warehouse club gas and grocery-affiliated stations are NOT coded as “gas stations” by most card networks. The Amex Blue Cash Preferred’s 3% applies only to US gas stations — not wholesale clubs.
Related: Best Cash Back Credit Cards | Best Grocery Credit Cards | Best No Annual Fee Cards | Best Credit Cards