Quick Comparison
Two retail giants, two competing memberships. Amazon Prime pioneered the paid loyalty program model; Walmart+ launched in 2020 as a direct competitor. Both promise free shipping and extra perks, but they serve different shopping needs.
| Feature | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Annual cost | $139/year | $98/year |
| Monthly option | $14.99/month | $12.95/month |
| Free shipping threshold | Any order | $35+ (most items) |
| Same-day delivery | Yes (select items/areas) | Yes (select items/areas) |
| Grocery delivery | Amazon Fresh (select areas) | Free from local Walmart |
| Gas discount | 10¢/gal at select stations | 10¢/gal Exxon/Mobil/Walmart |
| Streaming service | Prime Video | Paramount+ Essential |
| Music streaming | Prime Music | Spotify Premium (6 months) |
| Rx discounts | Amazon Pharmacy | Walmart Pharmacy |
| Student discount | Yes ($69/year) | No |
Bottom line: Prime offers more perks and better product selection. Walmart+ costs less and excels at grocery delivery and gas savings. Choose based on where you actually shop.
Membership Pricing Breakdown
Understanding the full cost picture helps determine true value.
Annual vs Monthly Pricing
| Plan | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Annual | $139 | $98 |
| Monthly | $14.99 | $12.95 |
| Annual savings over monthly | $41 (22%) | $57 (37%) |
Both programs penalize monthly subscribers. If you’ll keep the membership year-round, annual payment saves money.
Discounted Memberships
| Discount Type | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Student | $69/year (50% off) | Not available |
| EBT/Medicaid | $6.99/month | Not available |
| Trial period | 30 days | 30 days |
| Promotional offers | Occasional | Occasional |
Amazon’s student and low-income discounts make Prime significantly more accessible for qualifying households.
Price History
| Year | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | $119 | $98 (launch) |
| 2022 | $139 | $98 |
| 2024 | $139 | $98 |
| 2025 | $139 | $98 |
Amazon raised Prime to $139 in early 2022. Walmart+ has maintained $98 since launch, making it the consistent budget choice.
Free Shipping Comparison
Shipping benefits are the core promise of both memberships.
Shipping Speed and Availability
| Shipping Type | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Free 2-day shipping | Most items | Many items ($35+) |
| Free 1-day shipping | Millions of items | Select items |
| Free same-day delivery | Select items/metros | Select items/metros |
| Minimum order | No minimum | $35 for most free shipping |
| Geographic coverage | Excellent | Good, improving |
Amazon’s logistics network remains more extensive, meaning faster delivery to more addresses on more products.
Order Minimum Reality
| Order Size | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| $10 order | Free shipping | Pay shipping |
| $25 order | Free shipping | Pay shipping |
| $35 order | Free shipping | Free shipping |
| $100 order | Free shipping | Free shipping |
For small orders, Prime provides better value. Walmart+ requires $35+ for free shipping on most items, though some products ship free regardless.
Delivery Speed Comparison (Major Metro)
| Order Type | Prime Typical | Walmart+ Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Kitchen gadget | Next-day | 2-3 days |
| Phone case | Same-day or next-day | 2-3 days |
| Bulk paper towels | Next-day | Next-day or 2 days |
| Electronics | Same-day to 2 days | 2-3 days |
| Groceries | 2-hour windows | Same-day windows |
Rural/Suburban Reality
In less populated areas, both services slow down:
| Area Type | Prime Delivery | Walmart+ Delivery |
|---|---|---|
| Major metro | Same-day to 2 days | Same-day to 3 days |
| Suburban | 1-3 days | 2-4 days |
| Rural | 2-5 days | 3-5 days |
Grocery Delivery Comparison
Grocery delivery has become a primary use case for both memberships.
Grocery Service Overview
| Feature | Amazon (Fresh/Whole Foods) | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Service area | Select metros | 4,700+ Walmart stores |
| Delivery fee | Free (orders $35-150+) | Free (orders $35+) |
| Pickup option | Yes (Whole Foods) | Yes (all stores) |
| Delivery speed | 2-hour windows | 1-hour windows available |
| Product availability | Limited compared to in-store | Full store inventory |
Geographic Advantage: Walmart
Walmart+ has a massive geographic advantage for grocery delivery:
| Metric | Amazon Fresh | Walmart Grocery |
|---|---|---|
| Store count for fulfillment | ~40 Fresh stores + Whole Foods | 4,700+ supercenters |
| Population coverage | Major metros only | 90% of US within 10 miles |
| Rural availability | Very limited | Widely available |
If you don’t live near Amazon Fresh or Whole Foods, grocery delivery through Prime is limited or unavailable.
Grocery Pricing
| Item Category | Amazon Fresh | Walmart Grocery |
|---|---|---|
| Store brand (staples) | Competitive | Usually cheapest |
| Name brands | Competitive | Usually cheapest |
| Organic/specialty | Good selection, higher prices | Limited, lower prices |
| Produce quality | Good | Varies by location |
Walmart generally has lower grocery prices. Amazon Fresh competes on convenience and selection in areas it serves.
Real Cost: $400/month Groceries
| Factor | Amazon Fresh Household | Walmart+ Household |
|---|---|---|
| Membership | $139/year | $98/year |
| Monthly grocery spend | $400 | $380 (5% lower typical) |
| Annual grocery spend | $4,800 | $4,560 |
| Delivery fees | $0 | $0 |
| Total annual cost | $4,939 | $4,658 |
Walmart+ saves $281/year in this scenario through lower membership cost and lower grocery prices.
Gas Discounts
Both memberships offer fuel savings, but through different networks.
Gas Discount Programs
| Feature | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Discount amount | 10¢/gallon | 10¢/gallon |
| Where it works | Select BP, Amoco stations | Exxon, Mobil, Walmart, Murphy USA |
| Station count (approx.) | 7,000+ | 14,000+ |
| How to activate | Amazon app | Walmart app |
| Works with credit card rewards | Yes | Yes |
Gas Station Network Comparison
| Brand | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| BP | Yes | No |
| Amoco | Yes | No |
| Exxon | No | Yes |
| Mobil | No | Yes |
| Walmart stations | No | Yes |
| Murphy USA | No | Yes |
| Sam’s Club | No | Yes (with membership) |
Walmart+ has significantly more participating stations, especially through its Walmart gas station partnership.
Annual Gas Savings Estimate
| Annual Miles | Gallons (30 mpg) | Savings at 10¢/gal |
|---|---|---|
| 10,000 | 333 | $33 |
| 12,000 | 400 | $40 |
| 15,000 | 500 | $50 |
| 20,000 | 667 | $67 |
Gas savings alone won’t justify either membership, but they contribute to overall value.
Streaming and Entertainment
Digital entertainment is a major differentiator between the two programs.
Video Streaming Comparison
| Feature | Prime Video | Paramount+ Essential |
|---|---|---|
| Library size | Very large | Large |
| Original content | Extensive (The Boys, Rings of Power) | Good (Yellowjackets, Star Trek) |
| Live sports | Thursday Night Football, some soccer | NFL on CBS, Champions League |
| Ads | Ad-free tier included | Ads included |
| Offline downloads | Yes | Yes |
| Simultaneous streams | 3 | 3 |
| 4K content | Yes | Yes |
Prime Video has a larger library and more critically acclaimed originals. Paramount+ brings solid content including Star Trek franchises, Yellowstone spinoffs, and NFL games.
Standalone Value of Streaming
| Service | Standalone Price | Included With |
|---|---|---|
| Prime Video | $8.99/month ($108/year) | Amazon Prime |
| Paramount+ Essential | $7.99/month ($96/year) | Walmart+ |
Both memberships essentially include a streaming service worth roughly $100/year.
Music Streaming
| Feature | Prime Music | Walmart+ Music |
|---|---|---|
| What’s included | Prime Music (limited) | 6 months Spotify Premium |
| Library size | 2 million songs | Full Spotify (100M+ songs) |
| Ad-free | Yes | Yes (during promo) |
| After promo | Continues | Spotify at regular price |
Walmart+ includes 6 months of Spotify Premium (worth $60), but this is a one-time benefit for new members.
Additional Perks Comparison
Beyond shipping and streaming, both memberships include various extras.
Amazon Prime Extras
| Perk | Description | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Prime Reading | Free ebooks + magazines | ~$10/month value |
| Prime Gaming | Free games + Twitch benefits | ~$5/month value |
| Prime Photos | Unlimited photo storage | ~$5/month value |
| Amazon Music | 2 million songs | ~$5/month value |
| Prime Wardrobe | Try before you buy (clothing) | Convenience |
| Prime Day access | Exclusive sales events | Variable |
| Whole Foods discounts | Extra 10% on sale items | Variable |
Walmart+ Extras
| Perk | Description | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Paramount+ Essential | Streaming service | $8/month value |
| Spotify Premium | 6 months free (new members) | $10/month (6 months) |
| Mobile Scan & Go | Skip checkout lines in-store | Convenience |
| Early access to deals | Priority for sales/drops | Variable |
| Rx savings | Pharmacy discounts | Variable |
| Travel benefits | Hotel/rental car discounts | Variable |
Perks Value Calculation
| Membership | Core Benefit Value | Streaming Value | Other Perks | Total Approximation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon Prime ($139) | Shipping (~$100) | Prime Video (~$108) | Photos, Gaming (~$60) | ~$268 |
| Walmart+ ($98) | Shipping (~$60) | Paramount+ (~$96) | Gas, Scan & Go (~$30) | ~$186 |
By raw perk value, Amazon Prime offers more. But you only benefit from perks you actually use.
Pharmacy and Healthcare
Both offer prescription discounts, though through different models.
Pharmacy Comparison
| Feature | Amazon Pharmacy | Walmart Pharmacy |
|---|---|---|
| Discount program | RxPass ($5/month) | $4 generics list |
| Prime member discounts | Up to 80% off | Standard discounts |
| Delivery | Free 2-day | Free delivery or pickup |
| Insurance accepted | Yes | Yes |
| GoodRx compatible | Sometimes | Yes |
RxPass (Amazon Prime)
For $5/month extra, Prime members get unlimited fills of 60+ generic medications with no copays. This can be valuable for members taking multiple medications.
| RxPass Scenario | Traditional Cost | RxPass Cost |
|---|---|---|
| 1 generic medication | $4-15/month | $5/month |
| 2 generic medications | $8-30/month | $5/month |
| 3+ generic medications | $12-50+/month | $5/month |
$4 Generic List (Walmart)
Walmart offers $4 for a 30-day supply of many generics without any membership:
| Medication Type | Walmart Price | Available to |
|---|---|---|
| Metformin | $4/month | Anyone |
| Lisinopril | $4/month | Anyone |
| Amoxicillin | $4/month | Anyone |
| And 100+ more | $4/month | Anyone |
Who Should Choose Amazon Prime
Prime makes sense when you value broad selection, fast shipping, and entertainment.
| Shopper Profile | Why Prime Works |
|---|---|
| Frequent Amazon shoppers | Maximum shipping value |
| Students | 50% discount available |
| Streamers | Prime Video library |
| Urban dwellers | Same-day shipping access |
| Tech-forward households | Photos, Gaming, devices |
| Small/frequent orders | No minimum order |
Prime’s Unique Advantages
- No order minimum: Free shipping on $5 orders
- Same-day shipping: More products, more locations
- Student pricing: $69/year for verified students
- Prime Video: Larger library, better originals
- Prime Day: Access to exclusive sales
- Ecosystem integration: Alexa, Fire TV, Kindle, Ring
Who Should Choose Walmart Plus
Walmart+ excels for grocery-focused households and budget-conscious members.
| Shopper Profile | Why Walmart+ Works |
|---|---|
| Grocery delivery users | Better coverage |
| Rural/suburban families | More Walmart stores |
| Budget-focused households | Lower cost + lower prices |
| Gas station users | More stations, same discount |
| In-store shoppers | Scan & Go convenience |
| Paramount+ fans | Included streaming |
Walmart+ Unique Advantages
- Lower annual cost: $41/year cheaper
- Grocery coverage: 4,700+ fulfillment locations
- Gas network: 14,000+ stations
- Scan & Go: Skip checkout in stores
- Lower prices: Walmart everyday low prices
- Travel perks: Hotel and car rental discounts
Head-to-Head: Which Saves More?
Let’s model total annual savings for different household types.
Scenario 1: Heavy Amazon User ($300/month orders)
| Factor | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Membership | $139 | $98 |
| Annual orders | $3,600 | $3,600 |
| Shipping savings | $150+ | $80 |
| Streaming value used | $108 | $96 |
| Gas savings | $40 | $50 |
| Net membership value | +$159 | +$128 |
Prime wins for heavy online shoppers due to more shipping savings and no order minimum.
Scenario 2: Family with Weekly Grocery Delivery
| Factor | Amazon Fresh | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Membership | $139 | $98 |
| Annual grocery spend | $7,800 | $7,400 (5% lower) |
| Delivery fees | $0 | $0 |
| Gas savings (15k miles) | $50 | $50 |
| Total annual cost | $7,889 | $7,448 |
Walmart+ saves $441/year for this grocery-focused family.
Scenario 3: Suburban Family, Mixed Shopping
| Factor | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ | Both |
|---|---|---|---|
| Membership | $139 | $98 | $237 |
| Amazon orders ($150/mo) | $1,800 | — | $1,800 |
| Walmart groceries ($400/mo) | — | $4,800 | $4,800 |
| Shipping savings | $100 | $60 | $160 |
| Streaming used | Prime Video | Paramount+ | Both |
| Gas savings | $40 | $50 | $60 (one car) |
| Practical value | Good | Good | Maximum flexibility |
Some families find value in both memberships if they use both retailers regularly.
Special Situations
Best for Students
Amazon Prime wins decisively with 50% off ($69/year). Walmart+ has no student discount.
Best for Low-Income Households
Amazon Prime offers $6.99/month for EBT/Medicaid recipients. Walmart+ has no equivalent.
Best for Large Families
Walmart+ likely wins due to:
- Lower grocery prices
- Better grocery delivery coverage
- Lower membership cost
Best for Urban Singles
Amazon Prime likely wins due to:
- Same-day delivery availability
- No minimum order for small purchases
- Prime Video library
Best for Rural Households
Walmart+ likely wins due to:
- More Walmart stores in rural areas
- Better grocery delivery coverage
- More gas stations in rural areas
Can You Have Both?
Yes. Some households maintain both memberships when:
| Situation | Value of Both |
|---|---|
| Heavy Amazon + Walmart shoppers | Maximize shipping savings |
| Streamers who want both services | $205/year vs $204 separate |
| Families split on preferences | Everyone shops where they want |
| Deal hunters | Access all sales and promotions |
Combined Cost Analysis
| Approach | Annual Cost | What You Get |
|---|---|---|
| Prime only | $139 | Prime benefits |
| Walmart+ only | $98 | Walmart+ benefits |
| Both memberships | $237 | All benefits |
| Prime + Paramount+ separate | $235 | Prime + Paramount+ (with ads) |
| Walmart+ + standalone streaming | $146-200 | Walmart+ + chosen service |
Verdict
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Lowest cost | Walmart+ ($98 vs $139) |
| Best shipping speed | Amazon Prime |
| Best shipping coverage | Amazon Prime |
| Best grocery delivery | Walmart+ |
| Best gas savings | Walmart+ (more stations) |
| Best streaming | Amazon Prime (larger library) |
| Best for students | Amazon Prime (50% discount) |
| Best for families | Walmart+ |
| Best overall value | Depends on shopping habits |
Our Recommendation
Choose Amazon Prime if:
- You order from Amazon frequently
- You’re a student or qualify for discounted membership
- You live in areas with same-day delivery
- You want Prime Video over Paramount+
- You make many small orders under $35
Choose Walmart+ if:
- Grocery delivery is your primary use case
- You shop at Walmart regularly already
- You want to spend less on membership
- You value gas savings
- You live in a suburban/rural area with better Walmart coverage
Consider both if: You’re a heavy user of both retailers and want maximum flexibility. The $237 combined cost may be worth it for some families.
Related: Prime vs Costco Membership | Is Amazon Prime Worth It? | Target Circle vs Walmart+ | Instacart vs Amazon Fresh